A call for climate accountability: People of major industrialised nations support compensating low-income countries affected by climate change, EIB survey finds
KEY FINDINGS
- Most respondents say that the transition to a carbon-neutral global economy can only succeed if it also addresses inequalities (European Union: 68%; United States: 56%; China: 59%; India: 59%; and Japan: 62%).
- The rising cost of living, climate change and environmental concerns, and income inequalities are consistently ranked as the top three challenges. Climate and environmental issues are considered the top challenges in India and China, and the second most significant challenges in the European Union, the United States and Japan.
- There is a noteworthy consensus in favour of eliminating subsidies and tax breaks for the aviation sector and industries that rely heavily on fossil fuels (European Union: 74%; United States: 78%; China: 94%; India: 92%; and Japan: 71%).
- Most respondents from the European Union, the United States, China and Japan believe their countries should compensate developing nations for climate change impacts.
The European Investment Bank (EIB) on 29th November 2023 launched the sixth edition of its Climate Survey. These are some of the most striking results of this annual survey conducted in August and September 2023. Running since 2018, the EIB Climate Survey offers insights into the climate change-related views of people in major economies around the world, with more than 30 000 respondents in the European Union, the United States, China, India, Japan, the United Kingdom, UAE, Canada and South Korea. The EIB is the lending arm of the European Union and the world’s largest multilateral lender for climate action projects.
Climate change impacts and environmental degradation top the list of perceived challenges in India and China, while they are a close second to the cost of living in the European Union, the United States and Japan.
A clear majority of all respondents except those in Japan believe that measures to combat climate change will improve people’s daily lives, including the quality of food and health (European Union: 61%; United States: 66%; China: 69%; India: 65%; and Japan: 47%).
European and Japanese respondents are split on whether the green transition will create or eliminate jobs (51% and 49%, respectively) while their American, Chinese and Indian counterparts are more optimistic (57%, 70% and 63%, respectively) and believe net additional jobs will be created.
Demand for a just transition at home and in developing countries
Survey respondents recognise that the financial cost of the green transition is likely to affect personal budgets — especially those of lower-income households — and endorse policies that take social and economic inequalities into account to address the climate emergency. Most say that to succeed, the transition to a climate-neutral economy must also address inequalities (European Union: 68%; United States: 56%; China: 59%; India: 59%; and Japan: 62%).
However, some respondents lack confidence in the government’s ability to carry out such a fair transition. Most respondents in the European Union (62%) and Japan (60%) say they are not confident that their governments can address both challenges at the same time, whereas respondents in the United States, China and India are more optimistic, with 57%, 93% and 88% of respondents, respectively, trusting their government with this dual task.
Helping developing countries to deal with the impact of climate change
On the question of compensation to developing countries to help them deal with the impacts of climate change — expected to be a central topic at the 2023 UN Climate Change Conference in Dubai (COP28) —the survey shows that the global demand for fairness extends beyond national borders.
Conscious of a historical responsibility, most respondents from the European Union (60%), the United States (63%), China (74%) and Japan (72%) agree that their countries should financially compensate affected countries to help them fight climate change.
Taxes to support a just transition
Survey results show that most respondents would be willing to pay higher income taxes to help lower-income households cope with the costs of the green transition (European Union: 59%; United States: 67%; China: 90%; India: 89%; and Japan: 58%).
More specifically, 46% of EU respondents said they would agree to pay 1-2% more (United States: 40%; China: 59%; India: 45%; and Japan: 45%), and 13% of EU respondents would agree to pay as much as 5-10% more (United States: 27%; China: 31%; India: 44%; and Japan: 13%).
The vast majority of respondents also said they would be in favour of other kinds of environment-related taxes. For example, 74% of EU respondents said they would favour a fossil fuel tax reform (United States: 78%; China: 94%; India: 92%; and Japan: 71%) to eliminate subsidies and tax breaks for the aviation sector and other industries that rely heavily on fossil fuels.
Comments from EIB Vice-President Ambroise Fayolle, who is responsible for climate action and development at the Bank:
“The latest EIB Climate Survey underlines people’s profound awareness of climate change and their commitment to tackle it head on. They recognise that a successful transition to a climate-neutral world goes hand in hand with addressing social and economic inequalities at home and globally. At the European Investment Bank, we are fully committed to supporting a just transition that leaves no one behind. Solidarity and actionable measures are more important now than ever.”
Comments from Laura Sabogal Reyes, Senior Policy Advisor, E3G Public Banks Programme:
“The insights of the 2023 EIB Climate Survey leave no doubt. The global green transition will not be successful without addressing economic and social inequalities head on. Public Development Banks must play a crucial role in ensuring that the transition to a more sustainable and inclusive future is equitable and just, leaving no one behind.”
